Understanding the topic
Job-related criteria connect screening services and report information to actual responsibilities. The process should begin with the job, not with a list of every available search. Duties involving driving, funds, vulnerable populations, regulated credentials, systems, property, or management can support different packages and review factors.
For criminal records, the EEOC describes nature of the offense, time elapsed, and nature of the job as central considerations. Other services also require role logic—for example, an MVR for driving duties or employment credit information for a qualifying financial role where permitted.
Inputs for a role-based matrix
The matrix should explain both what is ordered and how information is reviewed.
- Essential duties, authority, access, location, schedule, vehicle, population served, and regulated requirements.
- Selected sources and what each source can and cannot establish.
- Nature, seriousness, timing, frequency, disposition, and factual relationship to the role where applicable.
- Candidate context, dispute rights, individualized assessment, and required notices.
- Decision ownership, escalation, documentation, exceptions, and review cadence.
How to develop criteria
A cross-functional process helps avoid rules based on instinct or isolated incidents.
- 1
Group similar roles
Use actual duties and access rather than title alone.
- 2
Identify legitimate requirements
Separate law, contract, client, insurance, policy, and preference.
- 3
Choose relevant sources
Order only services that answer a documented role question.
- 4
Define review factors
Create specific, consistent criteria and candidate-context procedures.
- 5
Test and monitor
Run scenarios, train reviewers, audit outcomes, and revise when roles or laws change.
Criteria that create avoidable risk
Broad exclusions can screen out qualified people and may not be job related.
- Rejecting anyone with any criminal record regardless of role, age, disposition, or time.
- Using arrest or charge information as though it were a conviction.
- Ordering credit, driving, medical, or sanctions information for roles without a documented connection.
- Allowing managers to apply unwritten personal standards.
- Using provider labels such as review or record found as the employer’s decision rule.
Governance and training
The matrix should be approved, accessible to authorized users, and reflected in system configuration.
- Document who owns criteria and who can approve changes or exceptions.
- Configure role packages so recruiters do not add searches casually.
- Train reviewers on dispositions, identity, source limits, and candidate procedures.
- Audit decisions and exceptions for consistency and potential adverse impact.
- Review criteria with qualified counsel when roles, locations, clients, or laws change.
Putting the information into a screening program
Job related and consistent with business necessity is a legal standard that should be applied with qualified guidance. This article provides an operational framework, not a legal conclusion for a specific exclusion.
The screening provider can explain sources and configure packages but should not make the employer’s hiring decision or invent the employer’s criteria.
Important legal and jurisdictional note
PRIMARY SOURCES
Sources and further reading
- Criminal Records: Tips for Small BusinessesU.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
- Questions and Answers About the EEOC’s Enforcement Guidance on Arrest and Conviction RecordsU.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
RELATED SERVICES
