Understanding the topic
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has explained that an employer's use of criminal history can create disparate-impact concerns and should be job related and consistent with business necessity. One approach described in the guidance is a targeted screen based on the nature of the crime, the time elapsed, and the nature of the job, followed by an individualized assessment in appropriate circumstances.
An individualized assessment is not the same as ignoring the employer's written criteria. It gives the person an opportunity to explain why the initial screen may not accurately predict risk for the specific position and allows the employer to consider reliable additional information under a consistent process.
Information that may be relevant to the assessment
The EEOC guidance identifies several types of context that may help an employer evaluate whether a record should affect the specific role.
- The facts or circumstances surrounding the offense or conduct.
- The number of offenses and the person's age at the time.
- Evidence that the person performed similar work after the event without known incidents.
- Employment, education, training, rehabilitation, or character references.
- Whether the person is bonded under a federal, state, or local bonding program.
A structured individualized-assessment workflow
The process should be documented, timely, and applied consistently to similarly situated candidates.
- 1
Apply the targeted screen
Compare the verified record with the employer's documented nature-time-job criteria.
- 2
Notify the candidate of the concern
Use the employer's approved communication and identify the information that may affect the decision.
- 3
Invite relevant context
Give the candidate a practical way and reasonable opportunity to provide information.
- 4
Review under consistent factors
Use trained reviewers and the same documented framework for similar roles and records.
- 5
Document the final reasoning
Record the job-related basis for the result without adding unsupported assumptions.
What the assessment does not replace
An individualized assessment sits alongside other employment and consumer-report procedures; it does not replace them.
- It does not resolve whether the report belongs to the candidate; identity and dispute review come first.
- It does not replace FCRA pre-adverse and adverse-action steps when a consumer report contributes to the decision.
- It does not make a blanket exclusion job related merely because exceptions are occasionally granted.
- It does not override a valid federal restriction or another role-specific legal requirement.
- It does not permit inconsistent treatment based on a protected characteristic.
Program-design questions
Employers should decide in advance who performs the assessment and which evidence will be considered.
- Define nature-time-job criteria for each role group rather than using one company-wide rule.
- Train reviewers on the difference between arrest, charge, conviction, dismissal, and disposition.
- Provide an accessible method for candidates to submit context and documents.
- Separate factual report disputes from requests for individualized consideration.
- Periodically review outcomes for consistency and potential adverse impact.
Putting the information into a screening program
The screening provider supplies report information and may facilitate candidate communications, but the employer determines job relevance and makes the decision. Employers should not ask the provider to create hiring criteria without the employer's legal and operational input.
State and local fair-chance laws can establish additional assessment factors, timing, notices, or forms. The employer should map those requirements to the location associated with the candidate and job.
Important legal and jurisdictional note
PRIMARY SOURCES
Sources and further reading
- Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment DecisionsU.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
- What You Should Know About the EEOC and Arrest and Conviction RecordsU.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
RELATED SERVICES
