Understanding the topic
Court records can show an arrest, complaint, indictment, charge, plea, conviction, acquittal, dismissal, deferred process, diversion, sentence, probation, appeal, or later modification. The terminology and legal effect differ by jurisdiction.
An employer should not reduce every case entry to found or clear. The reporting company should describe the current available source information, and the employer should use trained reviewers and job-related criteria.
Common disposition categories
These descriptions are general and should not replace the wording and law of the originating jurisdiction.
- Pending can mean the matter has not reached a final disposition or later source activity is still expected.
- Conviction generally reflects a judgment of guilt, but pleas, statutory labels, and later relief can affect context.
- Dismissed or acquitted is different from a conviction and should not be treated as proof of the charged conduct.
- Deferred adjudication, diversion, withheld judgment, or similar programs can have state-specific meaning and outcomes.
- Sealed, expunged, vacated, pardoned, or set-aside records require current source and legal review.
How to review a court result
A structured review starts with identity and source status before job relevance.
- 1
Confirm the person and jurisdiction
Use multiple identifiers and the originating court rather than a name-only database result.
- 2
Read the complete available docket or source
Identify charges, dates, amendments, plea, judgment, sentence, dismissal, and later orders.
- 3
Determine the current disposition
Avoid relying on an early filing entry when a later event changed the outcome.
- 4
Apply reporting rules
The consumer reporting agency evaluates reportability, completeness, and applicable limits.
- 5
Apply employer criteria
The employer evaluates lawfully reported information under documented nature-time-job and jurisdictional rules.
Why offense labels alone are insufficient
The same description can appear at different stages or under different statutes.
- A charge is an allegation and not the same as a conviction.
- An arrest record may not establish that the person engaged in the conduct.
- Counts can be amended, merged, dismissed, or resolved differently in the same case.
- Database summaries can omit later dispositions or use normalized labels that differ from the court.
- Pending cases, deferred outcomes, and post-conviction relief can require specialized legal review.
Review controls for employers
Decision-makers should understand the report without becoming amateur court clerks.
- Use the provider’s source-reviewed report and request clarification for unfamiliar dispositions.
- Train reviewers on the difference between arrest, charge, conviction, dismissal, and pending matter.
- Do not create automatic exclusions from offense names alone.
- Give candidates a meaningful dispute and context process.
- Review state and local restrictions on which dispositions may be considered and when.
Putting the information into a screening program
The EEOC distinguishes arrest and conviction records and explains that an arrest alone does not establish that criminal conduct occurred. Employers considering criminal history should assess job relevance and applicable law.
The provider does not determine whether a particular disposition disqualifies a candidate. The employer owns the reviewed policy and employment decision.
Important legal and jurisdictional note
PRIMARY SOURCES
Sources and further reading
- Questions and Answers About the EEOC’s Enforcement Guidance on Arrest and Conviction RecordsU.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
RELATED SERVICES
