Understanding the topic

Workers’ compensation records arise from workplace injury and benefit systems administered under state law. Depending on the jurisdiction and source, public information may be limited, restricted, or unavailable for employment screening. Even where records can be accessed, their use can raise disability, medical-information, retaliation, privacy, and state-law concerns.

An employer should not assume that a prior claim shows inability to perform a job, dishonesty, future injury, attendance risk, or increased cost. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has issued guidance on the interaction between workers’ compensation systems and the Americans with Disabilities Act.

Why this information is unusually sensitive

The source can reveal or strongly imply medical and disability information that is treated differently from ordinary criminal or verification data.

  • A claim can disclose an injury, condition, treatment, work restriction, or impairment.
  • State workers’ compensation systems differ in public access and permissible use.
  • Pre-offer disability-related inquiries and medical examinations are restricted under federal law.
  • Using claim history to screen out a person can create disability-discrimination or retaliation concerns.
  • A prior claim does not establish current inability to perform the essential functions of the role.

Questions before any search is considered

The safest workflow begins with legal review and may conclude that the search should not be used.

  1. 1

    Identify the actual business question

    Determine whether the employer is trying to assess essential functions, current restrictions, fraud, safety, or another issue.

  2. 2

    Evaluate lawful alternatives

    Consider whether a post-offer medical process, fitness assessment, reference, or ordinary qualification check is the appropriate tool.

  3. 3

    Review jurisdictional restrictions

    Obtain guidance on source access, timing, notice, disability law, medical confidentiality, and state workers’ compensation law.

  4. 4

    Limit access and scope

    If lawfully used, restrict the request and report to authorized personnel and the approved purpose.

  5. 5

    Separate medical and employment decisions

    Follow the employer’s accommodation, confidentiality, and job-related decision processes.

Inferences employers should avoid

A claim record provides historical context within a benefits system, not a prediction about the person’s future employment.

  • A claim does not prove that an injury was fraudulent or preventable.
  • A history of injury does not show that a person cannot perform the current job.
  • Claim frequency can reflect hazardous prior work rather than candidate conduct.
  • Public record availability does not make a search lawful or appropriate for hiring.
  • Medical and disability information should not be combined casually with ordinary background reports.

Program safeguards

Employers considering this area need specialized legal and occupational-health input.

  • Do not include workers’ compensation searches in a default package.
  • Document the legal basis, timing, purpose, source, decision owner, and confidentiality controls.
  • Keep medical information separate from ordinary hiring and background records.
  • Train recruiters and managers not to ask about prior claims or injuries outside the approved process.
  • Review the program for disparate treatment, retaliation, and disability-discrimination risk.

Putting the information into a screening program

The EEOC’s workers’ compensation and ADA guidance addresses hiring decisions, medical inquiries, return to work, and confidentiality. Employers should rely on current counsel for the specific jurisdiction and facts.

Express Background Checks should not be described as determining disability, fitness, accommodation, workers’ compensation eligibility, or legal compliance.

PRIMARY SOURCES

Sources and further reading

RELATED SERVICES

Continue with the service details

Review available workers’ compensation record services