Understanding the topic
Background reports can contain sensitive identifiers, criminal-record information, driving history, employment data, credit information, and candidate communications. Employers should know where those records are stored, who can access them, how long they are retained, and how they are destroyed when no longer needed.
Retention periods can be influenced by federal, state, local, contractual, litigation-hold, and internal-recordkeeping requirements. The goal is not to keep everything forever or delete it immediately, but to apply a documented schedule that is legally reviewed and operationally achievable.
Records that may need a retention decision
The screening file includes more than the final PDF. Employers should inventory the full workflow.
- Disclosure, authorization, certification, and jurisdiction-specific forms.
- The consumer report and any corrected or supplemental versions.
- Pre-adverse, dispute, individualized-assessment, and final adverse-action communications.
- Candidate documents, notes, and source clarifications received during review.
- Audit logs showing users, orders, access, exports, status, and delivery.
Creating a defensible retention lifecycle
A schedule should cover collection, storage, access, legal holds, routine disposal, and vendor responsibilities.
- 1
Inventory the records
Identify every system, inbox, integration, download location, and paper file that can hold screening information.
- 2
Assign retention categories
Map records to the employer's reviewed schedule, business purpose, jurisdiction, and legal obligations.
- 3
Restrict storage and access
Use approved systems, permissions, encryption, and unique user accounts rather than ordinary shared folders.
- 4
Apply legal holds
Suspend routine disposal for records relevant to a complaint, dispute, investigation, or litigation hold.
- 5
Dispose securely and verify
Destroy paper and electronic information so it cannot practicably be read or reconstructed, and document the process.
Common retention and disposal gaps
A written schedule does not protect information if copies continue to spread outside the controlled system.
- Recruiters downloading reports to personal desktops or uncontrolled shared drives.
- Reports attached to ordinary email or copied into chat platforms.
- Former users retaining access to the screening account or integration.
- Deleting the final report while leaving exports, notes, and attachments elsewhere.
- Using a fixed deletion date without a process for legal holds or corrected reports.
Controls to review with vendors
The employer and screening provider each manage different copies and responsibilities.
- Ask how long the provider retains reports, candidate information, audit logs, and dispute records.
- Confirm whether administrators can configure retention or download restrictions.
- Understand how integrations copy data into the ATS or HR system.
- Document offboarding, deletion, and data-return procedures if the provider relationship ends.
- Verify that paper and electronic disposal practices align with the employer's reviewed policy.
Putting the information into a screening program
The FTC's Disposal Rule requires covered entities to take reasonable measures to protect against unauthorized access to or use of consumer-report information during disposal. What is reasonable depends on the organization's operations and the sensitivity and volume of information.
Retention and disposal should be coordinated with equal-employment, recordkeeping, privacy, security, and litigation-hold requirements. Employers should obtain legal guidance rather than adopting a universal period from a vendor blog.
Important legal and jurisdictional note
PRIMARY SOURCES
Sources and further reading
- Disposing of Consumer Report Information? Rule Tells HowFederal Trade Commission
RELATED SERVICES
